Best Bites in Town
We asked the community to share their favorite restaurants, and the results are in! There was a diverse lineup of passionate nominations and must-try dishes from long-time classic pub foods to new neighborhood standouts.
Based on your votes, here are Delaware County’s top restaurants of 2025, ranked by the community and full of recommendations straight from local diners.
Amazing Joe’s topped the list for a reason. Locally owned and known for their great customer service, the menu covers just about everything—steaks, pastas, burgers, ribs, seafood, and comfort-food favorites. It’s the kind of place where everyone can find a dish they dig and the atmosphere feels reliably good.
What voters love:
- Ahi Tuna Steak
- Southwest Chicken
- Pomodoro Telle with Chicken
- Burgers & Steaks
- Hand-Cut Grilled Tenderloin
- Country Fried Chicken
Why you should go:
Consistency, big portions, friendly service, and a menu with zero misses.
Runner Up Bayleaf Indian Restaurant
Runner up was Bayleaf, a restaurant blending tradition and creativity to bring authentic Indian cuisine to Muncie. Located steps from Ball State University, it’s become the spot for comforting curries and those who love a little spice.
What voters love:
- Butter Chicken
- Chicken Curry
- Extra-spicy Chicken Tikka Masala
Why you should go:
Some of the best Indian cuisine in East Central Indiana.
Savage’s is the kind of spot that feels like home. With craft beers, classic American eats, a pool table, and retro character, it’s no surprise it was named Indiana’s Best “Hole in the Wall” Restaurant by Tasting Table in 2024.
What voters love:
- Wings
- Hand Breaded and Beer Battered Tenderloins
- Famous Grilled Cheese (stuffed with fried mozzarella sticks inside Texas toast!)
Why you should go:
For casual nights out, comfort food, and a vibe that’s unmistakably Muncie.
Find craft beer, pub fare, and live music all in one stop at Elm Street. Groups noted the quality beer and ever-rotating selection of specials.
What voters love:
- Array of Hand-Crafted Pizzas
- Pretzel Bites
- Wings
Why you should go:
A great hangout spot with good food, fun events, and unique brews.
4th Ron Lahody’s Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse
With exceptional hospitality, and over 200 bourbon and whiskey options, Lahody’s delivers a fine-dining experience locals swear by.
What voters love:
- 30-Day Dry Aged Steaks
- Seared Tuna Appetizer
- Ron’s Shrimp Cocktail
- Lobster Bisque
- Craft Cocktails + Standout Bartenders
Why you should go:
Meat lovers come for the steaks that never disappoint.
More Local Favorites
These restaurants also earned enthusiastic votes and plenty of love from locals:
Family-friendly spot near Crestview Golf Course
Try: Pizza, The Mulligan Tenderloin Sandwich
Historic 1865 home turned prohibition-era chophouse
Try: Filet Mignon (a fan favorite)
A Delaware County classic for 60+ years
Try: Royal Feast Pizza, Bread Stix
Homemade breakfast and lunch options
Try: Monte Cristo Sandwich, Spinach Salad with Hot Bacon Dressing, and Soups
Family-owned with daily homemade salsa
Try: Enchiladas, Victor Special (grilled chicken and shrimp covered with cheese sauce)
Affordable, authentic Chinese comfort food
Try: General Tso’s Chicken, Pork & Cabbage Dumplings, Northeastern Style Salad
Beloved breakfast & lunch hotspot
Try: Half-Pound Patty Melt, Onion Rings, Breaded Mushrooms
A favorite for flavorful, authentic Thai cuisine
Try: Red Curry, Adam Noodle, Garlic Fish
Fine dining with fusion cuisine and award-winning wine
Try: Baked Campanelle, French Onion Soup
Thanks to everyone who participated! Check out the full list of Delaware County’s vibrant restaurant scene!
